Vinyl vs Fiber Cement vs LP SmartSide: The Right Siding Choice for Terre Haute Homes

Choosing siding for your home in Vigo County isn’t just about color or style. Homes in Terre Haute & nearby areas take a beating from Midwest weather such as humidity, storms, freeze–thaw cycles, and strong sun. The wrong product or a shortcut install can mean warping, soft spots, peeling, and hidden rot years earlier than expected.

Request a Free Estimate

📞 Call 765-505-8383

This guide compares vinyl siding, fiber cement siding, and LP SmartSide engineered wood siding specifically for Vigo County and West-Central Indiana homes, and explains how the wall system behind the siding. Housewrap, flashing, starter strips, and proper installation directly affects durability, warranty, and long-term performance just as much as the product you choose.

Patriot Property Pros is a local siding contractor in Terre Haute, providing full wall-system installations with vinyl, fiber cement, and LP SmartSide designed specifically for Vigo County homes.

Why Your Siding Choice Matters in Vigo County’s Climate

Vigo County isn’t gentle on siding. Real-world conditions here expose weak products and weak installs fast, which is why the material you choose and the way it’s installed both matter. If you are looking for siding contractors in T

Local factors that put stress on siding systems include:

• Hot, humid summers that push moisture into any gaps, seams, or poorly detailed walls
• Cold winters and freeze–thaw cycles that turn hairline cracks into open joints
• Wind-driven rain across open fields and neighborhoods that forces water behind panels
• Clay-heavy soils that kick up muddy splash-back along the lower courses of siding
• Strong sun on south and west-facing walls that fades low-quality siding and dries out caulk
• Older framing, additions, and enclosed porches that are rarely flat, square, or consistent

Almost any siding can look good the week it’s installed. The real question for a Vigo County homeowner is how that siding system handles water, movement, and weather over the next 5, 10, or 20 years on your actual house—not just in a brochure.

How a Proper Wall System Protects Your Home

No siding product like vinyl, fiber cement, or LP SmartSide can perform the way it should if it’s installed over hidden damage, missing housewrap, or sloppy details. The structure behind the siding is what determines whether your new exterior lasts or quietly fails.

A long-lasting siding job in Vigo County should include:

• Full tear-off where needed so hidden rot, mold, or insect damage can be found and fixed
• Sheathing and framing repairs to create a flat, solid, stable base for the new system
• Continuous WRB/housewrap installed shingle-style as the primary drainage plane
• Proper flashing at windows, doors, band boards, decks, and roof-to-wall intersections
• Level starter strips set at the correct clearance above soil, mulch, porches, and concrete
• Correct fasteners, spacing, and expansion gaps based on the specific siding manufacturer’s requirements

When the wall system is built correctly, choosing between vinyl, fiber cement, and LP SmartSide becomes a strategic decision based on look, budget, and lifespan, instead of a gamble on whether the siding will survive Indiana weather.

Vinyl Siding: Cost-Effective and Common in Vigo County

Here’s your vinyl section rebuilt with clean, even lists (5 items each), ready to paste:

Vinyl siding is one of the most common choices for homes in Terre Haute, and the surrounding Vigo County area because it’s affordable, versatile, and performs well when installed over a proper wall system.

Pros:

• Typically the most budget-friendly full siding replacement option
• Low maintenance with no routine repainting required
• Wide range of colors, profiles, and trim styles to match different home designs
• Performs well when installed over solid sheathing with continuous housewrap and proper flashing
• Lightweight, making it suitable for older homes once walls are repaired, flattened, and detailed correctly

Concerns in Vigo County’s climate:

• Thin or low-quality panels can warp, crack, or rattle in strong sun, wind, and temperature swings
• Can appear wavy if installed over uneven framing or layered on top of existing siding
• More vulnerable to impact damage from hail, debris, lawn equipment, and everyday bumps
• Dark, inexpensive vinyl lines may fade or distort faster on sun-exposed elevations
• Poor installation practices (no tear-off, no WRB, no starter/clearance) can trap moisture and shorten lifespan

Best for:

• Homeowners who want a clean, attractive upgrade at a reasonable cost
• Households planning to stay in the home for roughly 5–15 years
• Projects where the contractor will perform tear-off, repairs, WRB, flashing, and proper starters—not just “cover over”
• Owners who prefer low ongoing maintenance and easy cleaning
• Rental and investment properties where curb appeal, durability, and budget all matter

Fiber Cement Siding (e.g., James Hardie): Premium and Durable

Fiber cement siding is a strong option for Vigo County homeowners who want a more substantial, long-term siding system that holds up to real Indiana weather.

Pros:

• Excellent durability against wind, impact, UV exposure, and temperature swings
• Non-combustible and resistant to insects and woodpecker damage
• Deep, crisp profiles that closely mimic traditional wood siding
• Performs reliably in West-Central Indiana when installed to manufacturer specifications
• Strong curb appeal and resale value, especially on higher-end homes and renovations

Key requirements:

• Heavier material that must be handled and installed by an experienced crew
• Requires proper flashing, joint details, and seam placement to prevent moisture intrusion
• Must maintain correct clearances from soil, concrete, roofing, and hard surfaces to avoid wicking
• Needs quality primer/paint systems and periodic repainting and caulk inspection over time
• Works best over a flat, repaired, fully wrapped wall system—not over old siding or soft sheathing

Best for:

• Homeowners planning to stay 15–30+ years and wanting a long-term solution
• Those who want a premium, wood-style look without traditional wood maintenance
• Projects where the budget supports both proper tear-off and higher-end materials
• Homes in visible locations where architectural detail and curb appeal really matter
• Owners who are comfortable with occasional paint and caulk maintenance to protect the investment

LP SmartSide: Engineered Wood Built for Real-World Conditions

LP SmartSide is an engineered wood siding and trim system that gives a true wood look with modern durability, especially effective on Midwest homes when it’s installed as part of a proper wall system.

Pros:

• Lighter and easier to work with than fiber cement, which is ideal for remodels and second-story work
• High impact resistance against hail, sports, and everyday bumps
• Attractive wood-grain appearance and modern profiles that suit many home styles
• Available with factory-finished colors for long-lasting appearance and reduced repaint cycles
• Engineered to resist moisture, decay, and termites when installed to LP’s specifications

Performance in Vigo County:

• Handles freeze–thaw cycles well when expansion gaps, sealant, and clearances are done right
• Works extremely well over quality housewrap, proper flashing, and level starter strips
• A smart choice for older homes once sheathing is repaired and walls are flattened
• Suitable for mixed exposures, including wind-driven rain, when detailed correctly at joints and trim
• Provides a solid balance of curb appeal, strength, and flexibility for West-Central Indiana conditions

Key requirements:

• Strict clearances from soil, concrete, decks, steps, and roofing to prevent wicking and saturation
• Proper LP-approved fasteners, spacing, and nailing patterns based on local conditions
• All cut ends, joints, and penetrations must be sealed exactly as LP requires
• Must be installed over flat, sound, wrapped sheathing—not used to hide structural or moisture issues
• Needs a contractor who follows LP SmartSide installation instructions, not “close enough” shortcuts

Best for:

• Homeowners who want a high-end wood look without the constant upkeep of real wood
• Long-term owners focused on curb appeal, strength, and predictable performance
• Projects where the wall assembly (tear-off, repairs, WRB, flashing, starters) will be fully upgraded
• Homes in visible neighborhoods where design, texture, and finish really matter
• Clients who want a premium siding system that still installs efficiently on remodel projects

Which Siding Lasts Longest on Vigo County Homes?

Assuming professional installation and a proper wall system behind it, each siding type can deliver a long service life in Vigo County.

Vinyl siding

• Typical life expectancy around 20–30 years with quality panels and correct installation
• Performs well when installed over repaired sheathing with WRB, flashing, and proper clearances
• Most vulnerable to shortcuts, cheap materials, and “cover over” installs
• Can be a solid, cost-effective choice when detailed correctly for our climate
• Best matched to homeowners wanting value, low maintenance, and flexibility

Fiber cement siding

• 30+ year potential with proper prep, paint systems, flashing, and maintenance
• Very stable and reliable in West-Central Indiana temperature swings
• Resistant to fire, insects, and common exterior damage when installed to spec
• Requires skilled installers and attention to clearances and joint details
• Ideal for long-term owners who want premium appearance and durability

LP SmartSide

• 25–30+ year potential when installed and maintained per LP’s guidelines
• Strong balance of impact resistance, curb appeal, and climate performance
• Works especially well on remodels and older homes with corrected wall systems
• Demands correct clearances, fasteners, and sealed cuts to protect the warranty
• A great fit for homeowners wanting a high-end wood look without traditional wood issues

In reality, all three systems can fail early or all three can perform extremely well. The difference comes down to installation questions like:

• Was old siding removed where needed so hidden problems weren’t buried?
• Was damaged framing or sheathing repaired instead of ignored?
• Is there a continuous, correctly lapped WRB/housewrap behind the siding?
• Are windows, doors, decks, band boards, and roof-to-wall areas properly flashed?
• Are starter strips level, straight, and kept off grade for drainage and durability?
• Did the installer follow the exact manufacturer instructions for the product installed?

If those boxes are checked, you can confidently choose between vinyl, fiber cement, and LP SmartSide based on budget, style, and how long you plan to stay in your home, instead of worrying whether the new siding will hold up.

Red Flags to Watch for in Siding Quotes

Vigo County homeowners should be cautious if they see any of these red flags during a siding quote or walkthrough:

Warning signs:

• “We’ll just install new siding over the old stuff” with no inspection or tear-off where needed
• No mention of housewrap, flashing, starter strips, or how the wall system will be built
• No clear plan for proper clearances at decks, porches, steps, and soil
• Vague, one-line quotes like “siding and labor” with no prep, repair, or detail included
• Contractors who can’t clearly explain how they handle windows, doors, corners, and roof-to-wall transitions

These shortcuts often lead to:

• Wavy, buckled, or loose siding along the lower courses
• Water leaks around windows and doors that show up inside later
• Rot at corners, band boards, decks, and ledger connections
• Trapped moisture behind siding, causing mold, soft sheathing, and structural damage
• Premature failure of even premium vinyl, fiber cement, or LP SmartSide products that should have lasted decades

How Patriot Property Pros Helps You Choose the Right System

When Patriot Property Pros looks at a siding project in Terre Haute or the surrounding communities, we’re not just asking, “Vinyl, fiber cement, or LP SmartSide?”

We start by evaluating the whole home:

• Existing siding layers, sheathing, and framing condition
• Moisture staining, rot, and soft spots at corners, band boards, and roof-to-wall areas
• Sun, wind, and water exposure on each elevation
• Decks, porches, steps, and grading that affect proper siding clearances
• Your budget, goals, and how long you plan to own the home

Then we design a complete siding system for your specific house:

• Remove siding where needed so hidden problems aren’t buried
• Repair, reinforce, and flatten the wall to create a stable, even base
• Install continuous WRB/housewrap shingle-style as the drainage plane
• Flash windows, doors, trim, decks, and roof-to-wall transitions correctly
• Set starter strips level and at proper height above soil, mulch, concrete, and porches
• Install vinyl, fiber cement, or LP SmartSide exactly to manufacturer specifications for our climate

This wall-first approach is what keeps Vigo County homes looking sharp, draining properly, and staying dry, not just the week after installation, but 10, 20, and 30 years down the road.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do vinyl, fiber cement, and LP SmartSide all need housewrap behind them?

Yes. All three siding systems should be installed over a continuous water-resistive barrier (WRB/housewrap). In Vigo County’s climate, housewrap is what protects the sheathing when wind-driven rain or moisture gets behind the siding. Skipping it shortens the lifespan of every product, no matter how “premium” the siding is.

Can I mix products, like using LP SmartSide or fiber cement on the front and vinyl on the sides?

Yes, and it’s common when designed correctly. Many Vigo County homeowners choose a premium material on the main elevations and a quality vinyl on less visible sides. The key is consistent wall prep, proper transitions, and flashing so different materials tie into one reliable system.

Is LP SmartSide or fiber cement safe for older homes with uneven walls?

Yes, as long as the wall is corrected first. On older Terre Haute and surrounding area homes, we repair or resheathe as needed, flatten the surface, install WRB, then install LP SmartSide or fiber cement to spec. Both perform very well once the base is solid; they should never be used to “hide” structural or moisture issues.

Is one siding type always the best choice for Vigo County homes?

No. There is no one-size-fits-all winner. Vinyl is great for budget and low maintenance, fiber cement excels at long-term stability and fire resistance, and LP SmartSide offers a high-end wood look with strong impact resistance. The best choice depends on your home’s condition, exposure, and how long you plan to stay after a proper wall inspection.

What happens if siding is installed over my old siding instead of tearing off?

Covering old siding makes it easy to miss rot, soft sheathing, and moisture damage. It also prevents installing continuous housewrap and proper flashings. That’s when you see wavy walls, leaks at windows and decks, and early failure, even with good products. For a long-term result, we recommend tear-off and rebuild where needed.

How does Patriot Property Pros help me choose the right siding for my home?

We start with an on-site evaluation: existing siding, sheathing, framing, moisture risk, decks, porches, and exposures. Then we price options in vinyl, fiber cement, and LP SmartSide as complete wall systems—not just “siding and labor.” You see exactly how each option will be installed on your home so you can choose based on look, budget, and lifespan with confidence.

Need further assistance?

Unsure about something? Get in touch with us for a personalized consultation.

Engage in a chat