Shower Replacement Cost in Terre Haute: Prices, Options, and Timeline

Replacing a shower is one of the fastest ways to upgrade a bathroom, especially if the current shower is dated, hard to clean, or showing signs of a leak. For many Terre Haute and Vigo County homes, a shower replacement is also the smart “preventive” move: fixing moisture issues early is almost always cheaper than repairing subfloors and framing later.

This guide breaks down typical shower replacement costs, what drives the price up or down, and how long the project usually takes.

Request a Free Estimate

Call 765-505-8383

Quick Answer

In Terre Haute, most shower replacements fall in the $3,500–$12,000+ range depending on the wall system (tile vs panels/solid surface), pan/base choices, plumbing updates, and whether hidden water damage is discovered. Full custom tile showers and layout changes can push totals into $15,000–$25,000+.

Shower Replacement Cost Ranges (Terre Haute)

Use these ranges to get a realistic starting budget. We also have a bathroom remodel calculator that you can use too.

What Counts as a Shower Replacement?

Homeowners use “shower replacement” to mean different things. On a job site, it usually falls into one of these:

• Replace the shower walls and pan/base while keeping the layout
• Convert a tub/shower combo into a walk-in shower
• Remove a failing tile shower and rebuild correctly
• Replace an outdated surround with a cleaner, lower-maintenance system

If you’re replacing because of a leak, the goal isn’t just “new tile.” The goal is a complete waterproofed shower system that stops water from reaching framing and subfloor.

The Biggest Cost Drivers

Two showers can look similar and still price very differently. These are the biggest drivers.

1) Shower wall system choice

In general, tile can look amazing, but it’s labor-heavy and depends on waterproofing details. Panel and solid-surface systems are often faster to install and lower maintenance.

2) Pan/base and drain setup

The shower pan/base and drain connection are common failure points in older installs. Replacing them properly matters. If the drain location lines up well with your new base and the plumbing is in good shape, costs stay closer to the lower end.

3) Plumbing updates

If the valve is old, leaking, or difficult to service, it’s often smarter to update it during replacement than to tear into a new shower later. Plumbing updates can include the mixing valve, shower head, diverter, and supply lines if they’re questionable.

4) Hidden water damage

Leaks don’t always show up where the problem is. Damage can travel along framing and subfloor seams. If demolition reveals rot or mold, the scope increases. This is one of the most common reasons estimates vary after a shower is opened up.

5) Access and demo complexity

Older tile showers with thick mortar beds, multiple layers, or tight bathrooms take longer to remove and rebuild. Stairs, tight hallways, and limited work space can also slow the process down.

Tile vs Panels or Solid Surface: Which Is Better for Terre Haute Homes?

There’s no one best option for everyone. It depends on your priorities.

Tile is a good fit when

• You want a custom look (niches, benches, patterns)
• You’re okay with ongoing grout care and sealing
• You want the most design flexibility for size and layout
• You’re investing in a long-term, premium shower build

Panels or solid surface are a good fit when

• You want lower maintenance and easier cleaning
• You prefer fewer grout lines and joints
• You want a cleaner install timeline with predictable results
• You want a modern look without the upkeep of grout

If your current shower is a leaking tile system, also see this guide on repair vs rebuild options:
https://patriotpropertypros.com/leaking-tile-shower-repair-cost-terre-haute/

How Long Does a Shower Replacement Take?

Timelines depend on scope, but here’s what’s typical.

1) Straight replacement (keep layout, no damage found)
Often several days.

2) Replacement with plumbing updates and custom details
Often about a week or more depending on materials.

3) Full tile rebuild with waterproofing, niches, benches, and drying time
Often 1–2+ weeks depending on scope and curing requirements.

4) One-day shower install (qualifying systems and bathrooms)
Often 1 day for installation once materials are ready, with a prior measuring and ordering step.

What qualifies for a true one-day shower install?

A one-day shower is usually a panel or solid-surface system paired with a compatible base, installed in a bathroom where the layout stays the same and there’s no significant hidden damage.

Most one-day installs work best when all of the following are true:

• Layout stays the same (drain and valve don’t move)
• No major water damage is found during demo
• The new system is a matched base + wall kit designed to install together
• The bathroom has normal access and no unusual framing surprises

If you want the smoothest timeline, choose materials early and avoid last-minute changes to fixtures or tile.

Signs You Should Replace Instead of Keep Repairing

A lot of homeowners call after repeated caulk and grout fixes. These signs usually mean replacement is the smarter investment:

• The shower leaks more than once or the leak keeps coming back
• Tile is loose, hollow-sounding, or cracking
• Grout stays dark, damp, or grows mildew quickly even after cleaning
• You see staining, swelling, or soft spots near the shower base or outside the shower

If you want the “why” behind leak symptoms and what’s happening behind the tile, this guide explains it:
https://patriotpropertypros.com/tile-shower-leak-causes-problems/

Repair vs Replace: The Practical Rule of Thumb

Repairs can make sense when the shower is newer and the issue is isolated. Replacement usually makes sense when the shower system itself is failing.

A repair may be worth it when

• The leak source is obvious and accessible (fixture or drain connection)
• The shower is relatively new and was built correctly
• Damage is minimal and limited to one small area
• You’re trying to buy time before a planned remodel

Replacement is usually the better move when

• Multiple “repairs” have already failed
• The waterproofing method is questionable or unknown
• There’s hidden damage in framing or subfloor
• You want better function, easier cleaning, or updated materials

What’s Typically Included in a Shower Replacement Estimate

Every contractor scopes differently, but most shower replacement estimates include some version of the items below.

Typically included

• Demo and removal of the old shower system
• New pan/base (or properly built shower pan for tile)
• New wall system (tile or panels/solid surface)
• Waterproofing method appropriate for the chosen system
• Basic trim, caulk, and finish details at the shower

Often not included unless specified

• Structural repairs (subfloor, studs, blocking) from hidden damage
• Moving drain or valve locations (layout changes)
• New flooring outside the shower area
• Electrical upgrades, lighting changes, or new ventilation
• Specialty glass upgrades beyond standard options

Common Upgrades That Change the Price Fast

These are the most common add-ons that can move a shower replacement estimate up quickly in Terre Haute homes:

• Moving the drain location (layout change or base compatibility)
• Relocating or upgrading the shower valve (especially in older plumbing)
• Adding a niche, bench, or custom tile detail (more labor + waterproofing steps)
• Upgrading to a heavier glass door system (thicker glass, better hardware, custom sizing)
• Subfloor or framing repairs found during demo (rot, softness, mold-affected materials)
• Ventilation upgrades (new bath fan, ducting fixes, or exterior vent correction)

Six Questions to Ask Before You Hire a Shower Contractor

These questions help you compare apples to apples and avoid “it looks nice, but leaks later” problems.

1) What waterproofing system will you use behind the walls?
2) How will the pan/base and drain connection be handled?
3) Will you replace or update the shower valve if it’s old?
4) How will you handle hidden damage if it’s found during demo?
5) Will you address ventilation to reduce moisture problems?
6) What workmanship warranty do you provide?

Local Tip for Terre Haute and Vigo County

If your home is older or you suspect the shower has been leaking for a while, budget with room for possible subfloor repairs. Catching the issue early is the difference between a straightforward replacement and a much larger rebuild, especially in older Terre Haute homes where moisture can travel under flooring.